The archive is fixed enough to criticize, with status notes kept outside the citable record.
Current review status
Track open criticism without changing the archive.
The CHC manuscripts are the fixed record. This page tracks what is currently most worth attacking, what would count as failure, and how a useful objection can become a correction, narrower claim, blocked route, retired label, or publicly inspectable test.
Status rule. Nothing on this page upgrades a claim. It only records uncertainty,
criticism, next checks, and correction pressure around the fixed archive. Entries marked internal
or maintainer are site-maintainer self-audits unless explicitly marked external.
Active review surface. The active review surface covers all 70 manuscript entries: 45 parent papers and 25 companion verification, support, public-stress, or validation-surface manuscripts. Companion manuscripts are independently reviewable, but their evidentiary weight is evaluated through the parent-paper claim, public-data window, or support lane they serve. Adding companion manuscripts to the active review surface does not upgrade validation, residue strength, external review status, or parent-paper closure.
Residue retirement rule. If ordinary domain theory and public data language account for the relevant local event, durable record, shared-fact, and interface-budget structure at the stated resolution, the CHC residue for that case is retired rather than promoted.
Status at a glance
Current verdicts stay bounded.
The ledger is most useful when it separates governance quality from scientific validation. These current labels show what narrows, what remains blocked, and what failed gate is still public.
| Area | Current status | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Detector records | orientation-only | All completed first-pass detector-family rows currently narrow the route rather than validate detector-physics residue. |
| Objectivity | likely redundant against SBS | The named SBS-classical-record case currently gives no stronger CHC shared-fact classification. |
| Interface budgets | candidate-only / blocked | The photoemissive thin-film case needs a public calibration map before branch-budget language carries weight. |
| Public data | public-rerunnable selection-stress failed | FRC/CHIME has a public rerun artifact, but the label remains a failed selection-stress condition, not support. |
Why this exists
Fixed archive, current objections.
A large manuscript series needs a clear status layer after publication. This page separates the citable archive from current objections, candidate downgrades, and next useful checks.
A strong objection can narrow a claim, force a correction, or retire a label.
The status layer identifies vulnerable claim families before asking readers to evaluate possible strengths.
A clean counterexample, collapse into standard language, or failed declared condition can directly weaken the lane.
The lane is mainly waiting for sharper comparison against established theory, terminology, or references.
The lane must be reduced to conserved, measurable, or reproducible quantities before it can carry more weight.
The lane is vulnerable to selection functions, retuning, weak baselines, and retrospective compatibility labels.
Evaluation posture
Governance quality is not the same as science validation.
Separate CHC research-program value from verified new-physics strength: governance quality can be high while external validation and surviving physical residue remain limited.
Evaluation posture. CHC is presently strongest as a bounded phase-background research program and boundary-audit grammar, not as a verified replacement theory. A mature downgrade schema, public reference anchor, or public rerun artifact must not be converted into a general science-validation score.
A candidate organizing lens for reading physical phenomena through local records, boundary conditions, and controlled recovery limits.
May be discussed as research-program promise or first-contact framing, not as established ontology.
Currently limited: detector rows are orientation-only, the named SBS objectivity case is likely redundant, interface budgets are candidate-only, and FRC/CHIME is a failed selection-stress window.
Keep any score here materially lower than review-governance scores unless a named residue survives ordinary comparators and external review.
Strong current value: one schema can narrow, downgrade, block, or retire CHC terms across detector, objectivity, interface, and public-data lanes.
High scores are acceptable only as claim-governance or review-infrastructure quality.
Still sparse: public-reference-anchored entries are inspectable maintainer self-audits, and the FRC/CHIME package is public-rerunnable but not supportive.
Do not raise validation language without recorded outside review, independent rerun, or archive-level result.
Review ledger
Four updateable lanes where criticism can move the project.
These are not promotional themes. They are pressure points: each one names the standard comparison, the possible collapse mode, and the next objection that would matter.
Lane 01 Open for falsification
Detector records
When does a threshold crossing become a recorded event?
- Current question
- Does any detector-record layer still exclude or classify a case that ordinary detector/readout/DAQ language does not already classify at the stated resolution?
- Strongest current risk
- SPAD, SNSPD, CCD, PMT, and bubble-chamber local-commit/count-status residues may be orientation-only bookkeeping rather than surviving CHC residue.
- Desired outside input
- External detector or instrumentation review of whether the SPAD/SNSPD/CCD/PMT/bubble-chamber orientation-only verdict is correct, or a known detector model where the proposed record-side layers cannot be separated by ordinary detector/readout/DAQ language.
- Paper trail
- 05, 06, 07, 10
- 70-entry scope
- Primary parent-paper route over Papers 05-07 and 10 inside the 70-entry review surface.
- Companion intake
- No companion manuscript currently carries an independent detector-record upgrade. Any companion objection that changes detector-record wording should be evaluated through the relevant parent-paper record claim and the detector comparison artifact.
- Smallest reproduction entry
- Start by comparing Papers 05-07 and 10 against a named detector family where threshold, commit, latch, durable output, and record counting are already explicit.
- Public issue state
- Issue #1 · open
- Last external input
- No external objection recorded in the site ledger yet.
- Last changed
- 2026-06-12
- Change summary
- The 2026-06-12 internal detector-readout verification pass preserved finite-window readout accounting while keeping QD/SBS objectivity untested and detector-record residues orientation-only.
Next useful moves
- Find detector models where these layers provably collapse.
- Identify standard references that already state the same grammar more cleanly.
- Route detector/instrumentation readers to the external-review request before changing any orientation-only verdict.
- Propose a minimal experiment or simulation where the orientation-only distinction becomes limited residue with observable or classification value.
Change history (12)
- 2026-06-12 · revised
Recorded the 2026-06-12 internal detector finite-window readout verification pass: PNR SNSPD and thermal-detector archives passed loadability checks, SNSPD core arrays plus 26 whichEventInfo NPZ files loaded, and 22 thermal NetCDF files loaded.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · initialized
Initialized lane from the detector-records review route with strongest known risk, desired outside input, and next useful checks.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added a SPAD layer-level first-pass verdict: threshold crossing, latch/reset, and durable output are treated as standard SPAD language; local commit and count status remain only narrow bookkeeping residues unless a stronger exclusion case is shown.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added public SPAD reference anchors and a second SNSPD first-pass verdict. Both detector families currently narrow the route: standard detector/readout language absorbs threshold, reset/latch, durable output, and counted-readout stages unless a later residue is shown.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added a CCD first-pass verdict and a standalone SPAD/SNSPD self-audit document. CCD also narrows the route: charge accumulation, well storage, transfer, digitization, and image records already carry most durable-record language.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added the residue retirement rule: if ordinary detector/readout/DAQ language accounts for the relevant local event, durable record, and count-status structure at the stated resolution, the detector-records residue is retired rather than promoted.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · downgraded
Reclassified SPAD, SNSPD, and CCD local-commit/count-status partial residues as orientation-only at the current resolution. They should become limited residue only if a later detector model, public reference, or experiment shows classification or exclusion value beyond ordinary detector/readout/DAQ language.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added a detector-records external-review request and issue template so detector/instrumentation readers can test whether the SPAD/SNSPD/CCD orientation-only verdict should remain, retire, or upgrade to limited residue.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Mapped the detector orientation-only verdict into the boundary-audit schema so local-commit/count-status language is visible as claim-status grammar, not a surviving detector-physics residue.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added evidence-status tracking to boundary-audit entries and added PMT plus bubble-chamber detector rows as comparison-pending targets rather than new residues.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · downgraded
Completed a public-reference-anchored PMT first-pass comparison: photocathode emission, dynode multiplication, anode pulse, discriminator, and counting language absorb the proposed layers at the current resolution, leaving local activation and counted-pulse status as orientation-only.
Source route - 2026-05-25 · downgraded
Completed a public-reference-anchored bubble-chamber first-pass comparison: ionization seed, bubble nucleation/growth, stereo photography, scanning, and track reconstruction absorb the proposed layers at the current resolution, leaving local-event and counted-track status as orientation-only.
Source route
Lane 02 Open for comparison
Classical objectivity
When is decoherence not enough for a shared fact?
- Current question
- Does the certificate ladder add anything beyond quantum Darwinism, spectrum broadcast structure, pointer stability, or open-system language, and where is it weaker, equivalent, or stricter?
- Strongest current risk
- The SBS-facing shared-fact certificate currently looks equivalent-or-weaker at the stated resolution, so stronger public-record language may be redundant unless a named classification difference is shown.
- Desired outside input
- Comparison table, counterexample, or reference showing where established objectivity criteria already account for the shared-fact structure at the stated resolution.
- Paper trail
- 08, 09, 10
- 70-entry scope
- Primary parent-paper route over Papers 08-10 inside the 70-entry review surface.
- Companion intake
- Companion objections are admissible when they affect the record/objectivity chain, but they should be routed through the parent-paper certificate claim rather than treated as separate validation.
- Smallest reproduction entry
- Start by mapping Papers 08-10 onto one established objectivity criterion such as quantum Darwinism, spectrum broadcast structure, pointer stability, or fragment-access consensus.
- Public issue state
- Issue #2 · open
- Last external input
- No external objection recorded in the site ledger yet.
- Last changed
- 2026-05-24
- Change summary
- Objectivity comparison artifact now includes a named SBS-classical-record likely-redundant verdict, and the boundary-audit schema frames that as CHC claim-status narrowing rather than a verdict on objectivity theory as a whole.
Next useful moves
- Map CHC certificates against established objectivity criteria.
- Mark every place where the shared-fact wording overstates what physics can certify.
- Separate useful vocabulary from duplicate terminology.
Change history (6)
- 2026-05-24 · initialized
Initialized lane from the classical-objectivity review route with comparison pressure against established objectivity criteria.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added an objectivity comparison artifact covering quantum Darwinism, spectrum broadcast structure, pointer stability, and fragment-access consensus.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Bound the objectivity lane to the residue retirement rule: shared-fact certificate wording is retired for a case when ordinary objectivity criteria already account for the boundary structure at the stated resolution.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Changed the spectrum broadcast structure row from comparison pending to likely redundant, with scope limited to an equivalent-or-weaker first-pass maintainer verdict at the current resolution.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Mapped the SBS-facing likely-redundant verdict into the boundary-audit schema so shared-fact certificate language is handled as bounded claim governance, not replacement objectivity theory.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Strengthened the SBS row from a generic first-pass verdict to a named SBS-classical-record case: disjoint environmental fragments redundantly carry the same pointer-state label, and CHC shared-fact wording is equivalent-or-weaker for that case.
Source route
Lane 03 Open for reduction
Interfacial branch budgets
How does absorbed excitation become externalized, retained, or dissipated?
- Current question
- Can the branch-budget grammar be tied to a fixed calibration map, measured inputs, conservation check, and public artifact status for one reproducible interface regime?
- Strongest current risk
- Branch labels may fail to close against absorbed excitation on one fixed calibration map, leaving the interface case candidate-only.
- Desired outside input
- Material-interface case or standard transport/optics formulation showing either a measurable residue or that ordinary interface language already accounts for the budget at the stated resolution.
- Paper trail
- 29, 29-1, 29-2
- 70-entry scope
- Parent Paper 29 plus its CBL companion entries within the 70-entry review surface.
- Companion intake
- CBL-VP0 and CBL-VP1 are reviewable as bounded public-pilot/support companions for Paper 29. They can narrow, block, or retire interface-budget wording, but they do not validate the parent branch-budget claim by themselves.
- Smallest reproduction entry
- Start with Paper 29 and a concrete material-interface example where externalized, retained, and dissipated channels can be measured or shown not to be conserved.
- Public issue state
- Issue #3 · open
- Last external input
- No external objection recorded in the site ledger yet.
- Last changed
- 2026-05-24
- Change summary
- Interface budget lane now requires calibration-map, measured-input, conservation-check, and public-artifact fields; the boundary-audit schema keeps the current row candidate-only until a public same-window artifact exists.
Next useful moves
- Name regimes where branch labels are not conserved or measurable.
- Compare the grammar against existing optical, detector, and transport formulations.
- State what public dataset could make this more than a retrospective story.
Change history (5)
- 2026-05-24 · initialized
Initialized lane from the interface-branches review route with branch-budget measurability and conservation as the main pressure point.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added a photoemissive thin-film candidate case mapping externalized, retained, and dissipated branch labels to measurable channel proxies.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Bound interface branch-budget wording to the residue retirement rule: ordinary optics, transport, material-response, or detector-interface language retires the CHC residue when it accounts for the same channels at the stated resolution.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added explicit calibration-map, measured-input, conservation-check, and public-artifact requirements to the photoemissive thin-film interface candidate.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Mapped the photoemissive thin-film case into the boundary-audit schema as candidate-only, preserving its organizer value while blocking stronger branch-budget language without a public calibration artifact.
Source route
Lane 04 Open for holdout discipline
Public-data stress windows
Can bounded CHC constraints survive public-data checks?
- Current question
- Which public results should be downgraded to null, unresolved, ordinary compatibility, or non-exclusion?
- Strongest current risk
- Public-data labels may overstate retrospective compatibility as support, or hide selection-function and tuning leakage.
- Desired outside input
- Selection-function objection, stronger baseline, holdout protocol, or dataset showing that a stated public-data label should be downgraded, blocked, or retired into ordinary compatibility.
- Paper trail
- 02, 02-1, 19, 19-1, 19-2, 19-3, 21, 22, 22-1, 23, 23-1, 23-2, 23-3, 23-4, 24, 24-1, 24-2, 26, 26-1, 26-2, 26-3, 27, 27-1, 28, 28-1, 28-2, 28-3, 28-4, 28-5, 28-6, 28-7, 29, 29-1, 29-2, 35, 35-1
- 70-entry scope
- Parent public-data routes plus all VP/KP validation, support, public-stress, and public-source companion entries inside the 70-entry review surface.
- Companion intake
- Each companion entry is reviewable on its own source basis, reproducibility boundary, label, and downgrade condition. Its evidentiary weight is still local to the parent claim or declared public-data window it supports.
- Smallest reproduction entry
- Start with one declared public-data window and ask whether the label survives a stronger baseline, selection-function check, and holdout or pre-registration discipline.
- Public issue state
- Issue #4 · open
- Last external input
- No external objection recorded in the site ledger yet.
- Last changed
- 2026-06-12
- Change summary
- The 2026-06-12 internal verification pass added bounded gate updates for DRK1 Catalog2/VOEvent, QAC/CBL/LBD proxy loadability, and BH/TDC/CMB reproducibility ledger checks while preserving all no-closure boundaries.
Next useful moves
- List the strongest selection-function objection for each window.
- Separate retrospective compatibility from predictive holdout value.
- Mark any label that requires post-hoc retuning or overstates support.
- Promote an internal audit to public-rerunnable only after a standalone artifact is exposed.
Change history (8)
- 2026-06-12 · revised
Recorded the 2026-06-12 internal verification results as bounded public-data/status-gate entries: DRK1 Catalog2/VOEvent remains blocked with 967 validated ids against expected 1109, QAC/CBL/LBD proxy surfaces load while finite-window, same-instance, and age-covariance closures remain open, and BH/TDC/CMB ledger checks pass without closure promotion.
Source route - 2026-05-25 · revised
Added the public GitHub Release rerun package for FRC/CHIME VP2 and promoted the evidence status to public-rerunnable while keeping the label selection-stress failed.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · initialized
Initialized lane from the public-data stress-tests route with downgrade pressure around selection functions, baselines, and holdout discipline.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added dataset-specific public-data windows so taxonomy labels are tied to named windows, baselines, selection risks, holdout boundaries, and downgrade conditions.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Added plain-language summaries, reproducibility-status fields, and an FRC/CHIME selection-stress reproducibility note that exposes the current boundary without claiming a rerunnable public package.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Reclassified FRC/CHIME from generic failed gate to selection-stress failed so the label names the failed selection/exposure condition rather than implying FRC-level failure.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Bound public-data windows to the residue retirement rule: when ordinary statistical, astrophysical, or public-data language accounts for a window at the stated resolution, the CHC residue is retired into the weaker ordinary label rather than promoted.
Source route - 2026-05-24 · revised
Mapped the FRC/CHIME public-data window into the boundary-audit schema as selection-stress failed, preserving the scoped failure label without implying parent-paper or framework failure.
Source route
Residue retirement
CHC residue must survive the strongest ordinary account.
The rule is a review discipline, not a global completeness claim about existing theory. It asks whether ordinary theory and public data language already account for the relevant boundary structure at the resolution being claimed.
A CHC term or layer survives only where the relevant standard theory/data language leaves a bounded classification, exclusion, or explanation gap at the resolution being claimed.
This is not a claim that existing theory is globally complete, and it is not a permission to keep CHC wording alive after a named case has collapsed into ordinary language.
Apply this case by case: first compare against the strongest standard detector, objectivity, interface, or public-data formulation; then keep, narrow, block, downgrade, or retire the CHC residue.
Boundary audit grammar Use one status grammar without turning it into a new validation claim. The common grammar audits CHC claim status against standard comparators. Open this section for the evidence ladder and full boundary-audit table.
Boundary audit grammar. CHC status language is used to audit CHC claim boundaries against the closest ordinary theory, instrument, interface, or public-data account; it is not a replacement for those accounts.
The grammar asks whether a CHC term is same, orientation-only, limited residue, blocked, retired, or otherwise narrowed for a named case at a stated resolution.
It does not claim that nature follows CHC ontology, that existing theories have been globally judged, or that a shared vocabulary is scientific validation.
Use this schema to compare bounded cases across detector, objectivity, interface, and public-data lanes while keeping each verdict subordinate to the strongest standard comparator.
A boundary-audit entry remains a maintainer self-audit unless an external reviewer, public rerun artifact, or review-ledger event explicitly changes its evidence status.
| Evidence status | Meaning |
|---|---|
| maintainer-self-audit | Internally structured comparison by the site maintainer; useful for routing criticism, not external validation. |
| public-reference-anchored | The comparison can be inspected against public references, while the verdict remains maintainer-scoped. |
| public-rerunnable | A public artifact can reproduce the declared classification, including a failed or stress label. |
| external-review | A named outside review input has stated evidence and a status effect in the ledger. |
| blocked | A required dataset, reference, calibration map, selection function, or artifact is missing. |
| Domain | Standard comparator | Boundary under test | CHC term | Verdict | Evidence status | Resolution | Why not stronger | Upgrade condition | Retirement condition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| detector | SPAD/SNSPD/CCD detector physics, readout electronics, DAQ streams, and stored acquisition records. | When local activation becomes a durable accepted detector record. | Local commit / count status | orientation-only | public-reference-anchored | Named detector-family first-pass rows for SPAD, SNSPD, and CCD on the current public review surface. | No named detector case currently shows CHC record-status language classifying an event beyond ordinary detector/readout/DAQ language. | A detector model, public reference, or experiment shows bounded classification or exclusion value not already supplied by ordinary detector/readout/DAQ language. | The proposed split remains fully covered by ordinary detector/readout/DAQ language for the named detector family at the stated resolution. |
| detector | Photomultiplier photocathode emission, dynode multiplication, pulse shaping, discriminator, and counting chain. | Whether amplification and discriminator-count status leave any CHC record-side distinction beyond ordinary PMT readout language. | PMT local activation / counted pulse boundary | orientation-only | public-reference-anchored | First-pass PMT detector-family row against public PMT photocathode, dynode, anode-pulse, discriminator, and photon-counting descriptions. | No named PMT case currently shows CHC local-activation or counted-pulse language classifying an event beyond ordinary photocathode, dynode, anode-pulse, discriminator, and counting language. | A PMT reference, model, or experiment shows a bounded record-status classification not already handled by photocathode, dynode, discriminator, and counting language. | Ordinary PMT detector/readout language accounts for the full threshold, amplification, discriminator, durable-output, and count-status chain at the stated resolution. |
| detector | Bubble-chamber ionization seed, bubble nucleation, track growth, imaging, and stored-frame analysis. | Whether macroscopic latch and visual track record status leave a CHC distinction beyond ordinary chamber/imaging language. | Bubble-chamber local event / durable visual record boundary | orientation-only | public-reference-anchored | First-pass bubble-chamber detector-family row against public ionization, bubble nucleation/growth, photography, scanning, and track-reconstruction descriptions. | No named bubble-chamber case currently shows CHC local-event or counted-track language classifying an event beyond ordinary ionization, bubble-growth, photographic, scanning, and reconstruction language. | A chamber reference, model, or experiment shows bounded classification value beyond ordinary nucleation, track-growth, imaging, and event-reconstruction language. | Ordinary bubble-chamber and imaging/reconstruction language accounts for the local event, latch, durable-output, and counted-track boundary more cleanly. |
| objectivity | Spectrum broadcast structure as a standard objective-record criterion. | Whether shared-fact certificate wording classifies objective-record structure differently from SBS. | Shared-fact certificate | likely redundant | maintainer-self-audit | Named SBS-classical-record case where disjoint environmental fragments redundantly carry the same pointer-state label. | For the named SBS-classical-record case, CHC certificate wording is equivalent-or-weaker and no current case shows it as stricter, useful-weaker, or differently classifying than SBS-style objective records. | A named case shows a different weaker/equivalent/stricter classification with clear public-record consequences. | SBS or another ordinary objectivity criterion accounts for the same public-record boundary more cleanly at the stated resolution. |
| interface | Photoemission yield, optical absorption, carrier transport, recombination, and thermal dissipation models. | Whether externalized, retained, and dissipated channels close on one fixed material-interface map. | Interface branch budget | candidate-only | blocked | Photoemissive thin-film interface candidate under fixed illumination, bias, and temperature window. | The case has no public calibration table, notebook, or dataset fixing the same-window channel map. | A public artifact exposes measured inputs and closes externalized, retained, and dissipated channels against absorbed excitation within declared uncertainty. | Ordinary optics, transport, material-response, or detector-interface language accounts for the same channels more cleanly, or the channels cannot be conserved on one map. |
| public-data | CHIME/FRB Catalog 1 selection, exposure, injection, and public-data stress-window language. | Whether a public-data result may be read as support, stress, failure, or only taxonomy. | FRC/CHIME public-data window | selection-stress failed | public-rerunnable | CHIME Catalog 1 injection-selection response-surface stress with a standalone public rerun package. | The declared efficiency-CV stress threshold failed, and the public rerun package reproduces that stress classification rather than converting it into support, closure, or a population-law result. | A stronger holdout artifact or selection-function analysis changes the named window status without retuning leakage. | A stronger ordinary selection-function, population, or baseline account absorbs the window, or the result remains only ordinary compatibility/non-exclusion. |
Concrete gates worth inspecting
Interesting examples remain bounded status objects.
These cases are useful because they show different outcomes: non-exclusion, proxy non-overturn, diagnostic partial, and public-rerunnable stress failure. None should be flattened into validation.
| Case | Technical anchor | Current safe status | Evidence status | Safe reading | What not to infer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DE-VP0 | Phase-flat background response compared against ordinary BAO, SN, and CMB-informed envelopes. | bounded non-exclusion | public-reference-anchored | Bounded non-exclusion. Review prompt:Challenge the declared comparison envelope, baseline choice, or whether ordinary background modeling already absorbs the route. | Do not infer dark-energy proof, full background-chain closure, or replacement cosmology. |
| CMB VP0 | Primary width, acoustic-angle, linked-ruler, and later-transfer diagnostic checks. | primary diagnostic partial | public-reference-anchored | Primary diagnostic partial. Review prompt:Challenge whether the width, acoustic-angle, linked-ruler, or transfer diagnostic is already fully handled by ordinary CMB analysis. | Do not infer full CMB likelihood closure, Boltzmann-code replacement, or cosmology validation. |
| FRC / CHIME | CHIME/FRB injection-selection response surface, efficiency-CV stress, and standalone rerun package. | selection-stress failed | public-rerunnable | Public-rerunnable selection-stress failed. Review prompt:Check whether the released rerun reproduces the failed selection-stress label and what stronger selection-function treatment would change it. | Do not infer CHC support, source-population inference, or full CHIME selection-function closure. |
| TDC-VP2 | Visible mass-profile, kinematic, public-chain, and modeling limits around time-delay lensing. | relaxed proxy non-overturn | public-reference-anchored | Relaxed proxy non-overturn. Review prompt:Challenge the mass-profile, kinematic, and public-chain assumptions before treating the proxy route as a cosmological result. | Do not infer a new H0 number, full time-delay inference, or model-family closure. |
Failed gates count. Public rerun does not mean support. It can also make failure
inspectable, which is why the FRC/CHIME failed selection-stress label remains visible.
Detector comparison verdicts Current detector verdicts narrow the route. These are site-maintainer self-audits, not validation claims. Open this section for the detailed detector-family comparison table.
Self-audit artifact. A concise reference-anchored detector-records audit is tracked in
docs/detector-records-spad-snspd-audit.md.
It is a maintainer self-audit, not external validation.
| Detector | Verdict | Public anchors | Failure consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPAD | First-pass internal comparison with public reference anchors: ordinary SPAD avalanche, quench/reset, pulse, timestamp, and count language account for the proposed layers at the current resolution; local commit and count status are orientation-only unless a later case shows exclusion value. |
| Detector-records wording should be narrowed for SPAD unless a later reference shows a record-side distinction not already carried by avalanche/quench/readout language. |
| PMT | First-pass internal comparison with public reference anchors: ordinary PMT photocathode emission, dynode multiplication, anode pulse, discriminator, and photon-counting language account for the proposed layers at the current resolution; local activation and counted pulse status are orientation-only unless a later case shows exclusion value. |
| Detector-records wording should be narrowed for PMTs unless a later reference shows a record-side distinction not already carried by photocathode/dynode/anode/discriminator counting language. |
| CCD | First-pass internal comparison: charge accumulation, well storage, transfer, digitization, and image-file construction account for the proposed durable-record language at the current resolution; stored charge versus accepted image/catalog record is orientation-only unless a later reduction case shows exclusion value. |
| Detector-records wording should be narrowed for CCD unless a later reference shows record-side value beyond standard charge-storage, transfer, calibration, and image-acquisition language. |
| SNSPD | First-pass internal comparison: hotspot formation, current diversion, voltage pulse, readout, and reset account for the proposed detector-record chain at the current resolution; local photon event versus counted readout record is orientation-only unless a later case shows exclusion value. |
| Detector-records wording should be narrowed for SNSPD unless a later reference or experiment shows a record-side distinction not already carried by hotspot/pulse/reset/readout language. |
| Bubble chamber | First-pass internal comparison with public reference anchors: ordinary bubble-chamber ionization, bubble nucleation/growth, photography, scanning, and track-reconstruction language account for the proposed layers at the current resolution; local event and counted-track status are orientation-only unless a later case shows exclusion value. |
| Detector-records wording should be narrowed for bubble chambers unless a later reference shows a record-side distinction not already carried by ionization/bubble-growth/photography/reconstruction language. |
Objectivity comparison artifact Keep shared-fact certificates under standard-language pressure. These entries are comparison handles. Open this section for the named comparator, verdict scope, redundancy risk, and next test.
| Comparator | Standard target | CHC certificate question | Verdict | Named case | Verdict scope | Redundancy risk | Next test |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quantum Darwinism | Redundant environmental records that make pointer-state information accessible from fragments. | Does the shared-fact certificate add a stricter public-record condition beyond redundant fragment access? | comparison pending | Pending: choose one redundant-fragment access scenario before assigning a case-level verdict. | No weaker/equivalent/stricter verdict yet; the row only names the comparison target. | The certificate ladder may simply rename redundancy and accessible pointer information. | Map each certificate step against redundancy, accessibility, and mutual-information criteria before keeping stronger language. |
| Spectrum broadcast structure | Objectivity from classically correlated system-environment states with redundant records. | Does CHC classify any case differently from the SBS objectivity condition? | likely redundant | SBS-classical record case: disjoint fragments contain redundant, classically readable records of the same pointer-state value, so the CHC shared-fact certificate is read as an orientation handle for the SBS objective-record condition rather than a stronger criterion. | Named-case maintainer verdict: equivalent-or-weaker for a spectrum-broadcast record in which disjoint environmental fragments redundantly carry the same pointer-state label. CHC shared-fact wording does not currently add a stricter, useful-weaker, or differently classifying boundary for that case. | Shared-fact wording currently duplicates a known structural criterion for objective records unless it can classify a non-SBS public-record case. | Retire or narrow stronger SBS-facing certificate language unless one named case shows CHC is stricter, weaker in a useful way, or differently classifies the record boundary. |
| Pointer stability | Stable pointer states selected by system-environment interaction and decoherence dynamics. | Does the certificate require recoverable public record status beyond pointer stability? | possible residue | Pending: separate a stable pointer-state selection example from a recoverable public-record example before retaining residue language. | Possible residue is limited to recoverable public-record status, not pointer-state selection itself. | If recoverability is not formalized, the certificate can sound stronger than pointer-stability physics permits. | Separate stable-state selection from public recoverability and mark any unsupported public-fact wording as narrow-only. |
| Fragment-access consensus | Multiple observers can infer the same state from disjoint environmental fragments. | Does consensus-bearing record status add anything beyond ordinary observer-fragment access? | comparison pending | Pending: choose a fragment-access consensus case before assigning same, likely-redundant, or possible-residue status. | No verdict yet; this remains a pending comparator until a failure or retirement case is named. | Consensus language can become vocabulary inflation if it has no different failure case. | State the failure case that would retire CHC shared-fact terminology for this comparator. |
Interface budget case Require measurable channels before branch-budget language carries weight. The interface lane remains open for reduction. Open this section for the candidate channel map and failure condition.
| Case ID | Material case | Standard comparator | Externalized channel | Retained channel | Dissipated channel | Calibration map | Measured inputs | Conservation check | Public artifact | Artifact template | Status | Failure condition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| INT-PHOTOEMISSIVE-FILM-01 | Photoemissive thin-film interface under fixed illumination, bias, and temperature window. | Photoemission yield, optical absorption, carrier transport, recombination, and thermal dissipation models. | Measured emitted charge/current or calibrated photoelectron yield. | Trapped charge, surface-potential shift, or internal carrier population proxy on the same declared window. | Thermal/phonon or non-radiative loss proxy from absorbed power minus measured externalized and retained channels. | One fixed illumination-spectrum, bias, temperature, film-thickness, absorption, and collection-efficiency map declared before interpreting branch labels. | Incident optical power or photon flux, emitted charge/current, absorption estimate, surface-potential or trapped-charge proxy, thermal/non-radiative loss proxy, and uncertainty budget. | Externalized plus retained plus dissipated channels must close against absorbed excitation within the declared uncertainty window before branch-budget language carries more than organizer status. | No completed artifact exposed; template available for a public same-window calibration table, notebook, or dataset. | Template | candidate case | If these channels cannot be measured or conserved on one fixed calibration map, branch-budget wording should stay narrow or blocked. |
Ledger sync
Manual issue sync status.
- Manual sync date
- 2026-05-25
- Issue comments checked through
- 2026-05-25 06:45 KST
- Sync method
- Manual site-ledger sync from the public review issue surface; future objections should be reflected here as dated status deltas.
Input rule
What moves the ledger.
The four canonical public review issues were opened and linked; no outside objection has been recorded in the site ledger yet. The active review surface now covers 70 manuscript entries, with companion manuscripts routed through their parent claim, support lane, or declared public-data window. The boundary-audit schema separates verdict from evidence status; PMT and bubble chamber are now public-reference-anchored orientation-only detector entries.
External input changes the ledger only when it names a bounded claim family, target page or paper, objection type, evidence, and proposed status effect.
Entries marked internal or maintainer are site-maintainer self-audits unless they are explicitly marked external. They are not independent validation, external peer review, or author-completed scientific verification.
Status effects
What an objection can change.
The ledger does not move by vague impressions. A useful issue should name the bounded lane, the evidence or comparison, and the proposed status effect.
The objection is out of scope, unsupported, already handled by the archive, or not tied to a bounded claim family.
The route remains open, but site wording, term translation, or guide text becomes more conservative.
A label or claim family loses strength because the objection shows weaker support, duplicate terminology, failed comparison, or stronger standard coverage.
The lane cannot be adjudicated until a named dataset, covariance, selection function, artifact, or access path exists.
A status label or CHC term is removed from the public surface because it is redundant, misleading, or unsupported.
Public-data label taxonomy Keep compatibility, stress, and support-language separate. Public-data labels are conservative status labels around declared gates. Open this section for allowed meanings, disallowed meanings, and downgrade triggers.
| Label | Allowed meaning | Disallowed meaning | Downgrade trigger |
|---|---|---|---|
| non-exclusion | The declared window has not excluded the bounded claim under the stated baseline and data limits. | A preference claim, verification claim, or evidence that CHC is favored. | A stronger baseline, selection-function correction, or reproduced null result removes the claimed window. |
| stress-pass | A declared stress gate was passed under fixed inputs and a stated comparison rule. | Theory support beyond that gate, or closure of the parent paper. | Gate inputs are retuned, the comparison rule changes after seeing data, or a stronger gate fails. |
| diagnostic partial | A limited diagnostic aligns with part of the declared checklist while other axes remain open. | Full model closure, same-instance proof, or general empirical confirmation. | The diagnostic is shown to be ordinary compatibility, insufficiently linked, or non-reproducible. |
| selection-limited compatibility | Compatibility remains only after foregrounding selection, exposure, or population-model limits. | Holdout success or source-population inference. | Selection modeling or exposure correction absorbs the apparent compatibility. |
| selection-stress failed | A declared selection or exposure stress condition failed inside a named public-data window. | A parent-paper failure, full-framework disproof, source-population inference, or global selection-function closure. | Any public wording that treats the failed stress gate as support, closure, or full-theory failure must be narrowed to the named selection/exposure condition. |
| blocked | The lane cannot currently decide because required data, covariance, baseline, or access is missing. | A failed result, a passed result, or a hidden supportive outcome. | The missing object becomes available and fails the declared gate or baseline comparison. |
| failed gate | A declared condition was not met for the named gate or window. | A full-framework disproof unless the gate was explicitly defined as decisive for that claim family. | The failure maps to a broader claim only when the ledger names the dependent claim and status effect. |
Public-data windows Bind each public-data label to a named window. Open this section for dataset, baseline, selection risk, retuning risk, holdout boundary, reproducibility, and downgrade conditions.
| Window | Plain summary | Dataset | Baseline | Selection risk | Retuning risk | Holdout boundary | Label | Reproducibility | Downgrade condition |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FRC-CHIME-SELECTION-STRESS FRC / public FRB route | Checks whether the CHIME/FRB selection and exposure surface can support the declared FRC window; the current result fails its declared efficiency-variation gate. | CHIME/FRB Catalog 1, live-injection table, synthetic injection sample, and exposure maps where available. | CHIME exposure and selection-surface stress against the declared fluence/exposure window. | Selection efficiency and exposure structure dominate the interpretation; the recorded efficiency-CV stress remains above the declared threshold. | High if fluence, exposure weighting, source-count fit, or shell organizer choices are changed after reading the stress output. | Retrospective public-data stress only; not a predictive holdout or full CHIME selection-function closure. | selection-stress failed | public-rerunnable GitHub Release package reruns to RERUN_OK classification=FRC-SELECTION-STRESS stress_reasons=efficiency_cv>0.3; ZIP SHA256 32f8eb7f25ce812c2b6e0fe8544a6585b28243ec9df1a77ea71a92f7e9e3dc75. | Any public wording that treats this as support, source-population inference, parent-paper closure, or full FRC failure should be narrowed to the declared selection/exposure stress condition. |
| DRK1-CHIME-CATALOG2-VOEVENT-HOLD DRK1 / FRC durable-record route | Records a blocked Catalog 2/VOEvent reconciliation window: 967 validated identifiers against the declared count of 1109, so no scored durable-record result is assigned. | CHIME/FRB Catalog 2 rows and VOEvent durable-record identifiers checked in the internal verification set. | Direct Catalog 2 validated VOEvent identifier reconciliation against the declared expected record count. | Catalog/alert semantics, identifier normalization, and durable-record coverage dominate the interpretation. | High if the expected identifier count, validation rule, or alert/catalog matching convention is changed after seeing the gap. | Retrospective durable-record reconciliation only; not a predictive holdout, source-count inference, or CHIME selection-function closure. | blocked | internal The 2026-06-12 internal verification pass reproduced the blocked reconciliation status; no standalone public rerun artifact is exposed here. | Any wording that treats this blocked reconciliation as a scored result, source-population support, or selection-function closure should be narrowed to blocked durable-record reconciliation. |
| DE-CMB-SAME-STACK-NONEXCLUSION DE / CMB public-chain route | Records a same-stack background-chain nonexclusion surface only; it is not a new CMB analysis or dark-energy closure. | Same-stack public background-chain comparison surface referenced by the audit-math empirical notes. | Standard background-chain nonexclusion check under the declared public inputs. | Low-to-moderate for the label itself, but high if readers treat nonexclusion as preference. | Any parameter or window change after the comparison would move the label back to blocked or diagnostic partial. | Non-holdout compatibility surface; not a CMB reanalysis and not a DE paper closure. | non-exclusion | internal Referenced through internal empirical notes; public-facing text must stay at non-exclusion until a standalone public artifact exists. | A stronger same-stack baseline, corrected covariance, or reproduced null window removes the nonexclusion label. |
| BH-TDC-CMB-REPRODUCIBILITY-LEDGER BH / TDC / CMB public-chain ledger | Records a reviewer-facing reproducibility ledger for public posterior, chain, archive, and inventory surfaces without promoting any likelihood or theorem closure. | GWOSC HDF5 files, TDCOSMO-chain status material, DESI DR2 ZIP inventories, and ACT DR6 tar inventories checked in the internal verification set. | Archive loadability, sample-read checks, CRC/inventory checks, and preservation of the existing bounded labels. | Low for file/loadability bookkeeping, high if readers treat the ledger as a substitute for domain likelihood pipelines. | Any change from ledger-readback to inference, likelihood, or replacement-analysis language would move the entry back to blocked. | Reproducibility ledger only; not LVK/EHT replacement, TDCOSMO full-likelihood closure, CMB likelihood or Boltzmann reanalysis, or parent-paper theorem closure. | diagnostic partial | internal The 2026-06-12 internal verification pass preserved the no-closure ledger status; no public standalone artifact is exposed here. | Downgrade or block any public text that converts archive/loadability checks into cosmological, black-hole, or time-delay inference support. |
| QAC-OBS-PROXY QAC public-observation route | Uses observation-proxy surfaces while the same-instance finite-window certificate remains open, so the label stays diagnostic partial. | MaNGA, Pipe3D, GEMA, and DAP FITS surfaces checked in the internal verification set. | Proxy-level observational comparison rather than same-instance simulation closure. | Proxy selection, survey coverage, and missing same-instance finite-window closure limit the label. | High if proxy thresholds are adjusted to compensate for missing same-instance finite-window data. | Proxy diagnostic only; no TNG same-instance holdout and no finite-window certificate closure. | diagnostic partial | partial Proxy loadability was reproduced while the same-instance finite-window certificate remained open; this is not closure, validation, or a public rerun artifact. | Treat as blocked if the missing simulation input is required for the stated claim family, or failed gate if the same-instance run becomes available and fails. |
| CBL-PUBLIC-PILOT-SAME-INSTANCE-OPEN CBL public-pilot route | Tracks the public-pilot branch-law material while same-instance branch tomography remains open. | CBL public-pilot and proxy/loadability surfaces checked in the internal verification set. | Public-pilot branch-law and proxy readback rather than same-instance closure. | Material, wavelength, interface, and branch-selection choices can dominate the apparent status if the same instance is not fixed. | High if thresholds or branch labels are adjusted after seeing proxy outputs. | Public-pilot diagnostic only; not same-instance branch tomography or parent-paper closure. | diagnostic partial | internal Included under the 2026-06-12 internal verification pass; the result is label preservation and loadability, not a public rerun or validation artifact. | Treat as blocked if same-instance calibration is required for the stated claim, or failed gate if a fixed same-instance run cannot close the declared branch ledger. |
| LBD-REINTEGRATION-CANDIDATE LBD withheld/reintegration route | Tracks whether a withheld LBD route can be reconsidered; the age/lookback gate remains open, so it is not restored to active status. | DESI DR2 y3 BAO cosmology public route plus SN triplet and background-envelope checks noted in the empirical ledger. | Radial-clock, xi-model competition, SN stability, background-envelope, and age-admissibility gates. | Age/lookback covariance and export objects remain the limiting missing input. | Moderate; the label must not hide that the age gate is still partial. | Reintegration-candidate status only; not restoration to an active series member. | diagnostic partial | partial The internal verification pass preserved the stress label and did not close age/lookback covariance or restore LBD to active status. | If age covariance/export objects fail the finite age-admissibility gate, downgrade from reintegration candidate to blocked or failed gate. |
Artifact status. FRC-CHIME-SELECTION-STRESS: Standalone public rerun package exposed as a GitHub Release asset; read it as rerun transparency for the failed declared efficiency-CV gate, not as support or closure. DRK1-CHIME-CATALOG2-VOEVENT-HOLD: Internal maintainer audit only: validated ids remain 967 against expected 1109, leaving gap 142 and keeping scoring blocked. DE-CMB-SAME-STACK-NONEXCLUSION: Use as a public-chain witness for nonexclusion only. BH-TDC-CMB-REPRODUCIBILITY-LEDGER: Internal maintainer audit only; the 2026-06-12 pass preserved BH VP2 hash/label boundaries, TDC VP2 relaxed proxy limits, and CMB DESI/ACT inventory checks. QAC-OBS-PROXY: Keep as diagnostic partial; the 2026-06-12 internal verification pass loaded QAC MaNGA/Pipe3D/GEMA/DAP surfaces without closing the finite-window route. CBL-PUBLIC-PILOT-SAME-INSTANCE-OPEN: Internal maintainer audit only; the 2026-06-12 pass preserved CBL public-pilot partial status and did not run same-instance closure. LBD-REINTEGRATION-CANDIDATE: Partial candidate with the age gate open; the 2026-06-12 internal verification pass preserved the stress label rather than restoring LBD.
FRC/CHIME reproducibility note. The public status now exposes a standalone rerun package for
the selection-stress failed result. The package reruns to
FRC-SELECTION-STRESS with
efficiency_cv>0.3; this is public rerun transparency for the failed declared stress condition,
not support, source-population inference, parent-paper closure, or full CHIME selection-function closure.
Update rule
How status changes are handled.
Fix the target
The Zenodo archive remains the citable source. This status page does not add claims; it points to what should be tested, corrected, or narrowed.
Expose the weak points
Every review lane names the failure condition before it names the attraction. That makes criticism legible and lowers the barrier for skeptical readers.
Move by deltas
A correction, failed gate, stronger theorem, better reference, or narrower label is recorded as a public status change rather than as a hidden edit.
Boundary
What the status page must not imply.
- Do not imply peer review where there is only public review.
- Do not present compatibility as confirmation.
- Do not hide failed gates; move them into the status record.
- Do not turn support, donations, or attention into research authority.
Invitations
Give different readers a clear first target.
Detector physics / open systems
Attack the record and objectivity lanes first. The most valuable contribution is a clean collapse, duplication, or sharper existing formulation.
Cosmology / public-data readers
Attack the stress-window labels. Look for selection effects, tuning leakage, weak baselines, and claims that should be downgraded.
Mathematical reviewers
Look for hidden assumptions, missing lemmas, non-equivalent translations, or places where vocabulary outruns theorem strength.
Editorial stance. The most valuable outside contribution may be a rejection, downgrade,
missing reference, or narrower formulation. This page exists so those changes become visible status changes.